Comparison
XLD Alternative for Mac: When Smol Fits and When It Does Not
Keep XLD if you rip CDs, verify rips with AccurateRip, or handle lossless formats like Monkey’s Audio and WavPack. It is free. Pick Smol, our Mac app, only if you want a simple $29 once converter and compressor for everyday audio plus images, PDFs and video.
XLD is the standard answer for lossless audio on the Mac, and nothing here changes that. We make Smol, so read with that in mind. Every XLD detail comes from the developer’s own page, read on 16 November 2026. Smol does not rip CDs, so it is an alternative for conversion only, not for ripping.
Smol vs XLD: feature by feature
| Feature | Smol | XLD |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $29 once for 1 Mac; Team $49 for 3 Macs; Enterprise $20 a seat | Free download, optional PayPal donations |
| Trial or refund | No trial, and purchases are not refundable | Not needed, it is free |
| Platform | macOS 13+ on Apple Silicon, macOS 14+ on Intel | Mac OS X 10.4 and later, universal binary |
| Rip audio CDs | — | ✓ |
| AccurateRip verification | — | ✓ |
| Cue sheets (split and image output) | — | ✓ |
| Outputs | AAC, M4A, MP3, WAV, FLAC, OGG, Opus | WAVE, AIFF, Raw PCM, Vorbis, AAC, MP3, Apple Lossless, FLAC, HE-AAC, Wave64, WavPack, Opus |
| Reads Monkey’s Audio, WavPack, TTA, DSD | — | ✓ |
| Write Apple Lossless or AIFF | — | ✓ |
| Bitrate and sample rate control | 16 to 512 kbps; 8 to 192 kHz | Not covered on its page |
| Batch and folders | Yes, mixed file types in one batch | Not covered on its page |
| Images, PDFs, video | Yes: compress and convert | No, audio only |
| Where files are processed | On your Mac, nothing uploaded | Local Mac app |
| Latest release | 1.0.35 | 20250302 (2 March 2025) |
Smol and XLD: pros and cons
Smol
Pros
- One $29 purchase covers audio, images, PDFs and video, with no subscription
- Bitrate from 16 to 512 kbps and sample rate from 8 to 192 kHz on every audio job
- Drag in files or whole folders, mixed types in one batch
- Watched folders, a Finder Quick Action and a menu bar tray
- An MCP server so Claude Code or Codex can run jobs locally
- Nothing is uploaded and there is no account
Cons
- No free trial, and purchases are not refundable
- Costs $29 where XLD costs nothing
- Cannot rip CDs and has no AccurateRip check
- No cue sheet support
- Cannot write Apple Lossless or AIFF, and cannot read Monkey’s Audio or WavPack
- Requires macOS 13 or later; XLD lists Mac OS X 10.4 and later
XLD
Pros
- Free, with optional donations
- Rips audio CDs, checks them against AccurateRip and writes WAV+cue or FLAC+cue images
- Reads Monkey’s Audio, WavPack, TTA, Shorten, DSD and embedded cue sheets
- Writes twelve output formats including Apple Lossless, AIFF and WavPack
- Universal binary that runs natively on Intel and Apple Silicon
Cons
- Audio only, no images, PDFs or video
- Some encoders are separate plugins you install yourself
- The latest release listed is 2 March 2025, so check it against your macOS version
- The page does not state a license, and the interface is built for audiophiles
When XLD is the better choice
For most lossless audio jobs, XLD is the right answer, and it costs nothing. Stay with it in these cases.
You rip CDs. XLD has been usable as a CD ripper since version 20080812. It checks rips against the AccurateRip database and can write a single image with a cue sheet. Smol has no ripping at all.
You work with unusual lossless formats. Monkey’s Audio, WavPack, TTA, Shorten and DSD files open in XLD. Smol does not read them.
You need Apple Lossless, AIFF or WavPack output. XLD writes all three. Smol writes AAC, M4A, MP3, WAV, FLAC, OGG and Opus.
You do not want to pay. XLD asks for optional donations only. Smol has no free tier, so XLD wins the price question outright.
What do XLD, MediaHuman and Smol cost?
Prices below are as of 16 November 2026. We only list a price when a vendor page states one.
| Tool | Pricing model | Price | Local or online |
|---|---|---|---|
| XLD | Free download, optional donations | $0 | Local Mac app |
| MediaHuman Audio Converter | See vendor site | See vendor site | Local desktop app |
| Smol Solo | One-time purchase | $29, one Mac | Local, nothing uploaded |
| Smol Team | One-time purchase | $49, three Macs | Local, nothing uploaded |
Smol has no free trial and no refunds. If you want to test before paying, XLD is free to try. The MediaHuman price is not on the product page we read, so see its site; our MediaHuman comparison has the rest.
What does XLD not do that Smol does?
XLD is audio only. If your week also includes shrinking photos, trimming PDF size or re-encoding a screen recording, you need a second tool. Smol handles those in the same window, and you can drop in a mixed batch.
On audio, Smol’s strength is control over file size: bitrate from 16 to 512 kbps and sample rates from 8 to 192 kHz on every job. Our guides on compressing audio and bitrate show what those settings do to a real file.
For converting a lossless library you already own, the common jobs are covered in FLAC to MP3 and WAV versus FLAC. Smol writes FLAC, so lossless to lossless works. It just will not write ALAC.
Which should you pick for a flac converter on Mac?
Read down the left column and stop at the first row that describes you.
| If this is you | Pick |
|---|---|
| You rip CDs or verify rips | XLD |
| You open APE, WavPack, TTA or DSD files | XLD |
| You need ALAC, AIFF or cue sheet output | XLD |
| You want audio conversion at no cost | XLD |
| You shrink audio, images, PDFs and video in one app | Smol |
| You want folders that convert what lands in them | Smol |
| You prefer one payment over donations and plugins | Smol |
Plenty of people will run both: XLD to rip and archive, Smol to make small copies for a phone or a podcast feed. If Smol’s job fits yours, see the $29 one-time purchase, and the best audio converters for Mac for the wider field.
How we checked this
We read the XLD developer page and the MediaHuman product page on 16 November 2026 and recorded formats, platforms, features and versions. We did not install or test XLD. Facts last checked . We make Smol, so treat our claims about it with the same care as any vendor’s, and see our editorial policy.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a one-time purchase alternative to XLD?
XLD is already free, with optional donations, so you only need a paid alternative for something it lacks. Smol is $29 once for one Mac, with free updates and no subscription. It converts and compresses audio, images, PDFs and video. It cannot rip CDs, read Monkey’s Audio or write Apple Lossless.
Can Smol rip CDs like XLD?
No. Smol cannot rip audio CDs and has no AccurateRip check or cue sheet support. XLD can rip discs, check them against the AccurateRip database and write a WAV or FLAC image with a cue sheet. If ripping is the job, use XLD and treat Smol as an optional second tool for conversion.
Does Smol convert FLAC?
Yes. Smol writes FLAC, WAV, MP3, AAC, M4A, OGG and Opus, with bitrate from 16 to 512 kbps and sample rate from 8 to 192 kHz. It will not write Apple Lossless or AIFF, which XLD does. For a FLAC library you want in MP3 or AAC, it is a fit.
Does XLD work on current Macs?
The XLD page says it works on Mac OS X 10.4 and later and is a universal binary that runs natively on Intel and Apple Silicon. The latest version listed is 20250302, released 2 March 2025, as of 16 November 2026. Check that release against your macOS version before you rely on it.
Why would anyone leave XLD for Smol?
Mostly for scope, not quality. XLD is audio only, with some encoders as separate plugins. Smol puts audio next to images, PDFs and video in one app with watched folders and a Finder Quick Action. If you rip or need unusual lossless formats, there is little reason to leave.
Keep reading